Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register  


You are here: Index > Eschatology > Eschatology > Topic : Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture

2


Threaded Mode | Tell a friend | Print  

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : mtmoulton March 2, 2010, 11:59 am
Hi Eternally Grateful,

That's great! 35 years is longer than I have been living! :)

Something I hope we can keep is that we will remain charitable through-out, I think many Christians make this a hill to die and I do not, but it is something to discuss and enjoy. I think as long as we believe in the literal return of Christ in the end to establish the new heavens and new earth, we are pretty much orthodox. I do have some quams, however, with your understanding of prophesy.


So do you go to a Calvary Chapel?


I do not think it is a salvic issue. So I do not think our eternal salvation is based on whether we get this right or not.  lol, so I agree.

I also love discussing it as long as people do not start fighting, not worth it.

And No I do not go to calvary chapel, to be honest, never heard of it..lol
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : mtmoulton March 2, 2010, 12:51 pm

I think the Bible is quite clear that Jesus sits as ruler as the fulfillment of the promise to David.  Does the prophesy deal with location? Or is it more concerned with lineage? Moreover, the "forever" is key, it meansthat Christ's kingdom will eternally, which started when he was lifted into heaven and took his rightful place at the right hand of God...

Daniel 7:13,14 states -

“I saw in the night visions,
and behold, with the clouds of heaven
there came one like a son of man,
and he came to the Ancient of Days
and was presented before him.
And to him was given dominion
and glory and a kingdom,
that all peoples, nations, and languages
should serve him;
his dominion is an everlasting dominion,
which shall not pass away,
and his kingdom one
that shall not be destroyed."

Isn't that the Christ taking his rightful place? And Aren't we (the Church) from all peoples, nations, and languages? Don't we all serve him? Doesn't he have an everlasting dominion? Hasn't that started NOW?

So, how hasn't the promise to David been fulfilled in Christ?

In Christ,

Mike M.


IU will just look here if this is ok.

according to daniel.

“I saw in the night visions,
and behold, with the clouds of heaven
there came one like a son of man,
and he came to the Ancient of Days
and was presented before him.
And to him was given dominion
and glory and a kingdom,
that all peoples, nations, and languages
should serve him;
his dominion is an everlasting dominion,
which shall not pass away,
and his kingdom one
that shall not be destroyed."


Have all peoples and nations and languages bowed down to worship Christ??

No,,

According to John, this will happen in Christ's thousand year reign on earth.  when satan is bound.. and all nations look to Christ the ruler of the earth.

That is until the end, when satan is loosed, and gathers an army,, yet this army can not and will not destroy Gods kingdom, it will be obliterated, then eternity will be ushered in with a new heaven and new earth.

Again, the world belongs to satan, It is not Christ's yet.

But remember, Christ is patient, willing that he should lose none, He will not come and establish his earthly kingdom until all his people are saved..

what about this promise to abraham.

Genesis 15:18 (NKJV)18 On the same day the Lord made a covenant with Abram, saying: “To your descendants I have given this land, from the river of Egypt to the great river, the River Euphrates—

Israel has never possessed this land in its entirety.. Didf God lie??  or will they one day possess this land as God promised??
Also notice how this covenant came to be.
It was tradition in which two people making a covenant between each other for both to walk between the parts of the sacrificed beasts, Meaning as long as both parties kep up their part of the bargon, the agreement was bound. If one failed, the other was not bound by the agreement.
God put Abraham to sleep, and God himself walked between the sacrificed animals. meaning the covenant was not bound but by God himself, Abraham or his descendants actions or inactions did nto matter, Even if they failed. God is bound to keep his promise.
Unlike the mosaic covenant, in which God keeping his promise is dependent on the people, if they failed, God was not obligated to keep his promise.






IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : mtmoulton March 2, 2010, 11:32 am
Here is a great resource that might help...

http://www.enjoyinggodministries.com/studies/eschatology/

Enjoy!


I do not believe acts 15: 14 - 17 is speaking of a future event..  As a dispensationalist. I have never even heard this taught, so not sure where this is coming from.

as for when the 70 years starts.

sorry but the decree to rebuild the temple and the decree to restore the city were not the same. This person is wrong in his assumptions.

If the decree cyrus gave in his first year was not just the temple, but the whole city.. then why in ezra 4 are the jews told to stop building, because they are building the city.. which they were not authorized to do..

if cyrus' decree was for the whole city. the jews,, who were trying to also rebuild the city gates, not just the temple, would not have been told to stop..








IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
Divinesoteriology
Group: Administrator
Posts: 487
Status:

Ordo Solutis) Drawing, Faith, Union with Christ which entails Justification, Regeneration, Adoption
Quote From : mtmoulton March 2, 2010, 9:12 am
Hey DS,

I just have a couple questions: Do you take everything in Revelation literally? Do you symbolize anything at all?  Also, what are the patterns that we find in Prophesy itself?

Did Jesus actually crush the head of the serpent? And did the serpent actually bite the heal of the seed? Or is that a symbol for something else?

Thanks,

Mike


There is no literal whore that sits on seven hills. So to your answer no. However, time tables in prophecy have always been literal. Take a look at old testament prophecy that was already fulfilled. It happened in the exact time table given. So my question to you is, if the time tables are always literal should it not also be literal in Revelations ?


-----------------------
Faith is not knowing what the future holds, but knowing who holds the future.
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
Divinesoteriology
Group: Administrator
Posts: 487
Status:

Ordo Solutis) Drawing, Faith, Union with Christ which entails Justification, Regeneration, Adoption
Quote
By your false understanding of "literal" interpretation, you therefore think that 
a red dragon will have seven horns, and it is SOOO big that it's
tail is going to sweep down stars down to earth (knowing that the
smallest star in the heavens is extremely larger than earth) and this
dragon is going to sweep 1/3 of them? This would be a "literal"
interpretation by your standards.


The key term in what I said was " whole thing" It is not a matter of symbolizing certain parts. It is a matter of people symbolizing the whole book.


-----------------------
Faith is not knowing what the future holds, but knowing who holds the future.
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
ronathanedwards
Group: Member
Posts: 192
Status:
Quote
The key term in what I said was " whole thing" It is not a
matter of symbolizing certain parts. It is a matter of people
symbolizing the whole book.


That is a sweeping statement which I do not think any amil or post mil theologian would accept. Like I said before, the book is not prophetic and apocalyptic correct.
Therefore each verse or statement has to seek the intention of the author according to it's genre.

Each idea has to be determined literally if it should be taken wooden or allegorically, metaphorically etc...

If, at the end of your study you find you have taken most of the book wooden OR allegorical it is still through the literal process.

Most amill people would say they are more literal than dispensationalists ...


Board Image



 


Edited by ronathanedwards : March 4, 2010, 9:53 am

-----------------------
Truth invites scrutiny, only error fears close examination. ~ Atruro Azurdia
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 4, 2010, 9:52 am


Most amill people would say they are more literal than dispensationalists ...



All catholics teach they do not believe in a works based gospel.. whciich we know to be false.

Saying it, and reality are two different things.

Dispensationalists believe in a literal 69 weeks, and a future 7 weeks ( of years)

they believe in a literal 3 1/2 year tribulation which this world has not witnessed (remember according to scripture. God has to intervene or else mankind would wipe itself out. This was not possible until the advent of Nuclear technology, which means only in the past 50 - 60 years could this have even been possible) for this reason alone the last seven years could not have happened yet..  Yet there are many other proofs this has not happened..

Again, I have only studied the catholic version of Amil.. If yours differs I would like to know how..




Edited by eternally-gratefull : March 4, 2010, 11:41 am
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
Divinesoteriology
Group: Administrator
Posts: 487
Status:

Ordo Solutis) Drawing, Faith, Union with Christ which entails Justification, Regeneration, Adoption
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 4, 2010, 9:52 am
Quote
The key term in what I said was " whole thing" It is not a
matter of symbolizing certain parts. It is a matter of people
symbolizing the whole book.
That is a sweeping statement which I do not think any amil or post mil theologian would accept. Like I said before, the book is not prophetic and apocalyptic correct.
Therefore each verse or statement has to seek the intention of the author according to it's genre. Each idea has to be determined literally if it should be taken wooden or allegorically, metaphorically etc...If, at the end of your study you find you have taken most of the book wooden OR allegorical it is still through the literal process. Most amill people would say they are more literal than dispensationalists ...


So lets get down to the time tables in Rev. Are they not literal?If not what grounds do you have to hold that they are not literal ?


Edited by Divinesoteriology : March 6, 2010, 12:54 pm

-----------------------
Faith is not knowing what the future holds, but knowing who holds the future.
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
ronathanedwards
Group: Member
Posts: 192
Status:
In Matthew 12:28, Jesus states, "But if I cast out devils by the Spirit of God, then is the kingdom of God come upon you."
What does Jesus say RIGHT AFTER that?

Else how can a man enter into a strong man's house and spoil his goods, except he first bind the strong man, and then spoil his house?
Why isn't that taken literally?

Jesus IS on the throne, the kingdom of God IS here, Satan IS bound. The martyred saints ARE at his side.

We are told in Ephesians 1:20-22 that Christ was set at God's right hand in the heavenly places and that all things are subject to him. This is describing the reign of Christ which is a present reality! Then, in Ephesians 2:6 that we are told that we sit together in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus! Revelation 20:4 teaches us that the first people to reign with Christ were those who were martyred beginning in the first century.


"Satan is the "god of this world" is not a subjective genitive, it is objective, in other words, The World's Idol, what it worships, is Satan. Satan is however a subject of Christ, and he IS bound.

Revelation 1:3 (ESV)
3 ..... blessed are those who hear, and who keep what is written in it, for the time is near. (or even "at hand")

Why isn't this taken literally?



A thousand years? So, Jesus who said His KINGDOM is NOW (which at the time was the first century) only lasted till 1000a.d. ?


Instead of assuming 1000 years is "literal" and using that as the default and thus asking for proof that it isn't, why not ask yourself (and I DO ask you) what proof do you have that makes it 1000 years?


In Psalm 50:10 God reminds us that, "For every beast of the forest is Mine, The cattle on a thousand hills." This does not mean that God only owns the cattle on exactly one thousand hills. Rather, it means he owns the cattle on ALL the hills, which is a rather large amount. The thousand year period described in Revelation 20 is the Kingdom of Christ, which began in the first century and will be delivered back to His Father at the consummation of history. (1 Cor. 15:24)



The resurrection described at the end of this thousand year period is none other than the resurrection associated with the final, bodily return of Christ in the future. 1 Corinthians 15:23 Paul writes, "But every man in his own order: the firstfruits is Christ, afterward, they that are of Christ, at his coming shall rise again."

On THAT DAY of His return is THE JUDGEMENT. There is only one. Every Judgement that is talked about is always linked to the LITERAL DAY of His coming. One return, one judement. The judgement of the sheep and goats.




-----------------------
Truth invites scrutiny, only error fears close examination. ~ Atruro Azurdia
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
Smart
Group: Member
Posts: 6
Status:
Pre-trib or No-trib for me.

I will defend neither. We are hardly even in the pre-end times.


-----------------------
Follower of The Way. Reformed. Defender of Truth.
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am
In Matthew 12:28, Jesus states, "But if I cast out devils by the Spirit of God, then is the kingdom of God come upon you."
What does Jesus say RIGHT AFTER that?

Else how can a man enter into a strong man's house and spoil his goods, except he first bind the strong man, and then spoil his house?
Why isn't that taken literally?

Jesus IS on the throne, the kingdom of God IS here, Satan IS bound. The martyred saints ARE at his side.



the flaw in this reasoning is this.

1. Satan is not bound, he still holds sway and control over the earth. Even paul recognized this when he said our battle is not against flesh and blood but against principalities and powers . if satan was bound, there would be no spiritual battles, for a person who is bound is can not fight. Also of note is that God sends his people into satans territory to rescue those who he came to save, this territory is said to be entered through the gates of hell..again, if satan was bound, there would be no gates to enter.. and finally, when satan is bound we are told that the whole world will worship Christ who is sitting on David's throne, This again has not happened yet.

2. Saints are still being martyred. Not all of them are at his side.

3. The spiritual kingdom of God is hear. as seen by the power of the Holy Spirit who empowers his people, and grants them the blessings promised, However, the literal kingdom of God where Christ actually sits on his throne after satan is bound and the whole world worships him has not yet happened.

4. Christ is on HIS throne, But he has yet to occupied the throne of David. This prophesy is yet to be fullfilled.

5. God is still binding the strong man, He has not completely bound him yet, Or we would have no satanic influence on the world.. What Christ was saying is before he can take his rightfull place on the throne of david, which the jews were searching for. He must first bind the strongman. He has yet to do this completely.

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am


We are told in Ephesians 1:20-22 that Christ was set at God's right hand in the heavenly places and that all things are subject to him. This is describing the reign of Christ which is a present reality!


do you think Christ likes the fact that drunks are killing innocent people. That people like Hitler are murdering millions, That satan still has control over many people??

Again. Yes all things are subject to him. They have been since the beginning of time,. But not all things are as of yet ruled by him, Again, Satan has not yet been bound..

this is not the same rule as described in revelation when satan will be bound. And christ has rule over all humanity..

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am


Then, in Ephesians 2:6 that we are told that we sit together in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus! Revelation 20:4 teaches us that the first people to reign with Christ were those who were martyred beginning in the first century.

"Satan is the "god of this world" is not a subjective genitive, it is objective, in other words, The World's Idol, what it worships, is Satan. Satan is however a subject of Christ, and he IS bound.



when satan is bound for 1000 years. there will be no satanic influence, Any satanic temptation,. any satanic rule. He may be bound as far as Gods children is concerned, yet even this is not a complete binding. For satan can even influence and tempt God's child just like he did Christ. He just can not harm them.. like he could not harm Christ unless God let him..

When he is bound, he can not tempt, influence or do anything against anyone on earth. Again, this is the difference.

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am


Revelation 1:3 (ESV)
3 ..... blessed are those who hear, and who keep what is written in it, for the time is near. (or even "at hand")

Why isn't this taken literally?


It is taken literally. The time of salvation is now. If we die, it is too late.

I also think the time that mankind has the ability to wipe itself off the planet is near. And that is why Christ will have to intervine at some point in the near future. It is at this time that Christ will set up his earthly kingdom, and bind satan for 1000 years

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am

A thousand years? So, Jesus who said His KINGDOM is NOW (which at the time was the first century) only lasted till 1000a.d. ?

Instead of assuming 1000 years is "literal" and using that as the default and thus asking for proof that it isn't, why not ask yourself (and I DO ask you) what proof do you have that makes it 1000 years?



Jesus saying his kingdom is now should not be interpreted as meaning the same as satan being bound for 1000 years.

Where did God say satan would be bound?

Rev 20: 1-1 NASB

1Then I saw an angel coming down from heaven, holding the key of the abyss and a great chain in his hand.  2And he laid hold of the dragon, the serpent of old, who is the devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years3and he threw him into the abyss, and shut it and sealed it over him, so that he would not
deceive the nations any longer, until the thousand years were
completed; after these things he must be released for a short time.

Notice what it says. He will bound in the abyss (bottomless pit) for a set period of time (1000 years) at which time he is not able to decieve the nations ( people who live on earth) for this set period of time.

What does it say will happen in the end? he will be released for a short period of time..
further study of scripture shows he makes one last try to decieve people, and build up his army.
since no time since Christ left earth has this happened. This prophesy has not been, nor is it being fullfilled yet. Satan is still deceiving the nations. He is NOT BOUND.
so not only is the prophesy of the 1000 years been seen yet. But satan has not even been bound yet.
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am

In Psalm 50:10 God reminds us that, "For every beast of the forest is Mine, The cattle on a thousand hills." This does not mean that God only owns the cattle on exactly one thousand hills. Rather, it means he owns the cattle on ALL the hills, which is a rather large amount. The thousand year period described in Revelation 20 is the Kingdom of Christ, which began in the first century and will be delivered back to His Father at the consummation of history. (1 Cor. 15:24)



this does not speak as to what will happen in the 1000 years., Satan is not bound in the abyss, He is still deceiving the nations. So this attempt of destroying the literall 1000 years does not work..It would only work if satan had actually been bound the last 2000 some odd years. Which has not happened.

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 12, 2010, 8:58 am


The resurrection described at the end of this thousand year period is none other than the resurrection associated with the final, bodily return of Christ in the future. 1 Corinthians 15:23 Paul writes, "But every man in his own order: the firstfruits is Christ, afterward, they that are of Christ, at his coming shall rise again."

On THAT DAY of His return is THE JUDGEMENT. There is only one. Every Judgement that is talked about is always linked to the LITERAL DAY of His coming. One return, one judement. The judgement of the sheep and goats.




There are actually 2 judgments spoken of in scripture,

the BEMA judgement, where Christs children are rewarded for their works.

and the great white judgment, where all unbelievers (dead in Christ) are judged also for their works. But recieve no reward because they are condemned for unbelief.

secondly, the ressurection you speak of does not happen after the 1000 years. For satan must be released and the final great battle must ensue.. before evil is completely destroyed and this ressurection takes place.


IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
ronathanedwards
Group: Member
Posts: 192
Status:
Quote
Satan is not bound, he still holds sway and control over the earth 


Satan "holding sway" does not contradict him being bound.  He can not do anything that Jesus on the throne does not allow him to do.

Quote
When he is bound, he can not tempt, influence or do anything against anyone on earth. Again, this is the difference 


This is interesting since men will DIE in the millennium. Death is because of SIN. Yet there will be no Satan to tempt men? 



Quote
But not all things are as of yet ruled by him 


All things are SUBJECT to him. A SUBJECT is one who is RULED.


ALL the Church fathers believed that the Anti-Christ would be seen by the Church. This definitely rules out any pre-trib rapture. This includes Polycarp who was a disciple of John. 



-----------------------
Truth invites scrutiny, only error fears close examination. ~ Atruro Azurdia
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 16, 2010, 8:08 am


Satan "holding sway" does not contradict him being bound.  He can not do anything that Jesus on the throne does not allow him to do.



according to john he will not be able to do anything. according to you, being bound means he can do some things, but only if God lets him.

I hate to say it. but that has been true since the beginning of time. thus it can not be what John spoke of. Satan has never been outside of Gods control. I think the fact that satan was held in check according to Job proves this.. he could only do what God allowed him to do.

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 16, 2010, 8:08 am


This is interesting since men will DIE in the millennium. Death is because of SIN. Yet there will be no Satan to tempt men? 



no there will not. John makes it perfectly clear he will be bound and unable to do anything..

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 16, 2010, 8:08 am


All things are SUBJECT to him. A SUBJECT is one who is RULED.



well, again, this has been since the beginning of time. what differentiates him ruling by soverign decree in the OT from this time prophesied?? 

Quote From : ronathanedwards March 16, 2010, 8:08 am


ALL the Church fathers believed that the Anti-Christ would be seen by the Church. This definitely rules out any pre-trib rapture. This includes Polycarp who was a disciple of John. 



this does not prove anything.

Fact is both pre-trib and mid trib has more biblical backing than does post trib, (which has basically none) or amill..

in fact, many apostles were looking for Christ to return while they still lived.. this would rule out amil, since none expected to live 1000 years..


IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
ronathanedwards
Group: Member
Posts: 192
Status:
Quote From : ronathanedwards Today at 9:08 am

This is interesting since men will DIE in the millennium. Death is because of SIN. Yet there will be no Satan to tempt men? 


no there will not. John makes it perfectly clear he will be bound and unable to do anything..


So why do men sin and die in the millennium? Who are they tempted by?


Anyways, I should not have allowed myself to get sucked into this topic. There are far to many other things that need to be dealt with.

You keep waiting for the rapture, and I'll keep looking for the Return of Christ. Either way, we meet Christ.

-----------------------
Truth invites scrutiny, only error fears close examination. ~ Atruro Azurdia
IP: --   

Pre-Trib, Post Trib, Mid Trib, or no Trib Rapture
eternally-gratefull
Group: Elite Member
Posts: 292
Status:
Quote From : ronathanedwards March 16, 2010, 12:38 pm


So why do men sin and die in the millennium? Who are they tempted by?




men die because the fall of man and the failure of the body is still active until God removes it..

men sin because they still have old sin natures. I hope your not one who thinks it is satan who makes us sin. I sin even without satanic influence. I sin because it is in my nature. as it is in every mans nature. we do not need satan to make us sin.


IP: --   

« Previous    Next »

Threaded Mode | Tell a friend | Print  

2


Jump To :


Users viewing this topic
1 guests, 0 users.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is September 9, 2010, 1:41 am.

  Powered By AEF 1.0.8 © 2007-2008 Electron Inc.Queries: 11  |  Page Created In:0.088

Caughtup Ministries